Summary
Meghan Trainor would be the perfect replacement for Katy Perry onAmerican Idol, and she has what it takes to be successful on the reality singing competition series. Katy was anAmerican Idoljudge for seven years alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. They were the original judging panel when ABC revived the show in 2018 after its 2016 cancelation by FOX. Now Katy is leavingAmerican Idolto focus on her own music career.
There have been many suggestions about who should replace Katy onAmerican Idolseason 23. They include formerAmerican Idoljudge Jennifer Lopez, Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus, andAmerican Idolseason 22 mentors Jelly Roll and Jon Bon Jovi. In addition,American Idolalums Ruben Studdard, Clay Aiken, Fantasia Barrino, and Jordin Sparks have been mentioned as possible successors of Katy. There are so many amazing artists to choose from, butMeghan would be the best replacement for Katyfor the following reasons.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Meghan Really Wants To Be An American Idol Judge
Meghan Has Gone To Great Lengths To Get The Job
In an interview withET,Meghan expressed how much she wants to become anAmerican Idoljudge. She said,“There’s nothing I want more in life than to be a judge on American Idol. That is my ultimate bucket list dream come true.“Meghan continued,“Please, please consider me [laughs] on your show. Please American Idol! Please! I’m ready. Alright, yeah, I would love to.”
In addition, in a segment fromWatch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, shared via YouTube, Meghan shared, “I have emailed three awesome people who work in that world who don’t really have the full say, but I’ve begged.“However,Meghan hasn’t heard any updates.Meghan would be a fabulous judge because she wants the job badly, and therefore would put her whole heart and soul into it.
Meghan Loves American Idol
Meghan Has Been Watching The Reality Singing Competition Series Since She Was A Child
American Idolhas been a special part of Meghan’s life since she was a kid. In her interview onWatch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, she explained,“It’s my favorite show. I’ve watched it since I was a child.“It’s important for anAmerican Idoljudge to honor the legendary history of the show, and, as a lifelong fan, Meghan would be able to do that.
Meghan Trainor Is A Talented Singer & Songwriter
Meghan Has Won A Grammy Award
Meghan is a very talented singer and songwriterwho has many hit songs, including “All About That Bass,” “Lips Are Movin,” “Marvin Gaye” (duet with Charlie Puth), “Better When I’m Dancin',” and “Made You Look.” She also won the 2016 Grammy Award for Best New Artist. Meghan knows what it takes to be a success in the music industry, so she’d know what to look for duringtheAmerican Idolauditions. She would bring even more expertise to the panel when she joined the already established judges, Lionel and Luke.
10 Celebrities Who Should Take Katy Perry’s Place As An American Idol Judge
Beloved American Idol judge Katy Perry announced that season 22 is her last. Here are some celebrities who could take her place on the judging panel.
Meghan Has The Endorsement Of The American Idol Cast
Host Ryan Seacrest & Judge Luke Bryan Want Her As A Judge
After Meghan mentored theAmerican Idolseason 22 Top 12 contestants during Billboard #1 Hits Night,host Ryan Seacrest and Luke gave her their support to replace Katyin an interview withET. Ryan gushed,“She was very good. Meghan is a super talent, too, and she’s got a great sense of humor. She’s fun and she’s spontaneous. I love Meghan Trainor.“Luke also sang Meghan’s praises, stating,“I think Meghan’s always been real fun. You know, that’s kinda been her brand, to have fun. [She’s] real witty, so certainly.”
It’s important for theAmerican Idoljudges and host to have camaraderie. When there’s tension among them, it’s hard to watch. This was never more true than duringAmerican Idolseason 12 when Mariah Careyand Nicki Minaj feuded for most of the season. The show became more about their rivalry than the contestants. Since Luke and Ryan are already on board for having Meghan join the show, she should definitely be considered. Ryan has worked with everyAmerican Idoljudging panel since season 1, so his opinion should be trusted and taken seriously.
Another Woman Is Needed On The American Idol Judging Panel
Katy Should Be Replaced By A Woman
Katy’s replacement should be a woman. There’s never been a judging panel made up solely of one gender in the history ofAmerican Idol. Not only do women bring their own perspective to the show, but Katy proved that having a strong woman role model such as herself can help the female contestants to thrive. A woman is needed to balance Lionel and Luke, and Meghan is the perfect choice.
Meghan Is A Successful Pop Star
Pop Must Be Represented On American Idol
The threeAmerican Idoljudges should represent three different genres of music. With Lionel covering R&B and soul, and Luke coming from the country music world, Katy’s replacement must be a pop star like her.American Idolbegan asPop Idolin the United Kingdom, which proves that the show is really searching for the next big pop star. As a pop star,Meghan should take Katy’s seat, so that the genre continues to be represented.
I’m Convinced Jennifer Lopez Is Returning To Judge American Idol For This One Reason
Former American Idol judge Jennifer Lopez has said that she won’t have time to replace Katy Perry, but a recent development could change everything.
Meghan Has A Big Personality
Meghan Can Fill The Void Left By Katy
ThroughoutAmerican Idol, Katy was known for her big personality. She had many hilarious moments on the show, and she kept the audience laughing. Katy was also known for dressing in elaborate costumes during Disney Night, including Snow White, Ursula, Mrs. Jumbo, Tinker Bell, Ariel, Elastigirl, and Cinderella. While Lionel and Luke are more subdued, Katy is brilliant and bold.Like Katy, Meghan is known for her fun and quirky personality, so she would be an ideal choice to take her place.
Meghan Was A Fantastic American Idol Mentor
Meghan Mentored The American Idol Season 22 Top 12
Meghan was able to participate in the experiences of theAmerican Idolseason 22 Top 12 contestantswhenshe served as their mentor during Billboard #1 Hits Night. When she mentored the Top 12 contestants, it was obvious that she was invested in their experiences and wanted to help them succeed. She has a big personality, but she didn’t steal the spotlight from them, which is also very important.
In herWatch What Happens Live with Andy Coheninterview,Meghan shared that she loves watchingAmerican Idolcontestants become superstars and following their journeys from their auditions. She said,“I love being a part of their process. I just get way too attached.“Katy’s love for the contestants was apparent in her judging, duets with them during the finales, and herAmerican Idolseason 22 dress, which featured the faces of every Top 24 contestant from her era of the show on her skirt. Meghan would be that kind of judge as well.
10 Best American Idol Disney Night Performances From Seasons 16-21
The American Idol S22 Top 5 will sing Disney classics on the annual Disney Night. Here’s a look back at ten magical Disney Night performances.
Meghan Has Judged Other Reality Singing Competition Shows
Meghan Has Experience In The Genre
American Idolwouldn’t be Meghan’s first time working on a reality singing competition show. In addition to her stint asanAmerican Idolmentor, Meghan was a judge onAustralian Idolseason 8 in 2023. She also was a coach onThe Voice UKseason 9 in 2020, and served as the advisor of Team Blake Shelton onThe Voiceseason 8 in 2015. In addition, Meghan was a judge onThe Four: Battle for Stardomduring seasons 1 and 2 in 2018. Meghan has a lot of experience with mentoring, coaching, and judging, so she’s a logical choice to replace Katy.
Meghan wants nothing more than to become anAmerican Idoljudge. With Katy’s exit, the time is now for her to take on the role. With her experience as a pop star and as a reality singing competition series judge, her boisterous personality, and her love forAmerican Idol, Meghan is the perfect choice to replace Katy.Hopefully,American Idolseason 23 will welcome Meghan to the judging panel.
American Idol
Cast
American Idol is a reality singing competition that adds to the international “Idol” brand, conceived initially in the U.K. as Pop Idol. Holding massive auditions across the U.S., American Idol invited several contestants to perform in front of a panel of judges that would determine whether or not they’d go on to future rounds for a chance at competing in the fully televised premiere of the show. Contestants are voted off each week by American participation via voting through various mediums, and the winner of the competition would be given a contract with a record label to secure a future as America’s next musical idol.
